The Harry Potter Remake’s First Casting Wave Eases One Of My Earliest Fears
HBO’s Harry Potter remake has eased one of my earliest fears about the upcoming series by announcing the first six actors who will play prominent characters. Casting rumors about the Harry Potter show have been swirling for months now, but we finally have an update on who will portray several adult characters. John Lithgow had already confirmed he’d be playing Dumbledore in the remake, but he has been officially announced alongside five other actors: Janet McTeer (McGonagall), Paapa Essiedu (Snape), Nick Frost (Hagrid), Luke Thallon (Quirrell), and Paul Whitehouse (Filch).
The Harry Potter remake’s first casting wave comes as a relief, partly because it’s high time some of the stars for the reboot were confirmed — and partly because it eases fears that arose after initial conversations and fan-castings. Naturally, when HBO’s TV series was announced, fans immediately started speculating about who might join the cast. It will be hard to top the cast of the original adaptations, but I’m glad the HBO reboot isn’t leaning into stunt casting to overcome that challenge.
The Harry Potter Remake’s First Casting Wave Confirms The Show Won’t Use Stunt Casting
A-List Actors Were Initially Being Discussed For Major Roles
When shows and movies are eager to sell viewers on their casts, some will embrace stunt casting: bringing big Hollywood names on board to draw a wider crowd. The Harry Potter TV show could have done this instead of looking for veteran actors and talented newcomers, hoping to capitalize on the interest in celebrities and A-listers playing familiar roles. Fortunately, it doesn’t look like the HBO series is going in that direction, at least if its earliest announcements are anything to judge by.
Related
The Harry Potter Remake’s Success Depends On Its Ability To Get 6 Things Right
HBO’s Harry Potter remake faces many challenges ahead of its expected 2026 premiere, but nailing these things makes it more likely to succeed.
But big-name stars were being discussed as possibilities after the reboot’s announcement, with Cillian Murphy being a favorite fancast for Voldemort. Rumors about him have made the rounds, and at one point, the possibility of Rachel Weisz playing Minerva McGonagall was also tossed around. While these actors would no doubt bring star power to the franchise, an IP like Harry Potter doesn’t really need it. The movies prove how well a mash-up of seasoned character actors and lesser-known names can work, while stunt casting would be far riskier.
Stunt Casting Would Have Been A Terrible Choice For The Harry Potter Show
It Would Have Been Distracting & Felt Gimmicky
The thought process behind stunt casting is that it will garner more interest in a project, but this approach would have been a terrible choice for the Harry Potter remake. For one, it would prove distracting, and the shift from the movies’ cast to the reboot’s will already risk taking viewers out of the story. The inevitable comparisons are among the harshest realities the Harry Potter series faces, and it would be very obvious if the HBO series tried to overcome this issue by leaning into star power.
In addition to the A-list celebrities distracting from the characters and their stories, this approach would also feel gimmicky.
In addition to the A-list celebrities distracting from the characters and their stories, this approach would also feel gimmicky. Warner Bros. is clearly trying to expand its biggest fantasy IPs with new Harry Potter and The Lord of the Rings content, but fans are all too aware of when something feels like a money grab and when it feels genuine. Going too heavy on widespread recognition would place the remake in the latter category. However, its combination of veteran stars and lesser-known actors will likely work to its advantage.
The HBO Remake’s Mix Of Veteran Actors & Newcomers Offers Hope For Its Success
It’s The Same Formula That Worked For The Movies
The Harry Potter show wouldn’t have benefited from utilizing stunt casting, but its current strategy of mixing veteran actors and newcomers sets it up for success. Talent like Lithgow, McTeer, Essiedu, Frost, and Whitehouse are all experienced enough that they inspire confidence in the upcoming remake. However, their inclusion doesn’t feel like a purposeful attempt to secure high viewership numbers. They’ll be able to make the roles their own, fully immersing viewers in their performances. And newer stars, like Thallon, bring their own unique talents to the series.
HBO’s Harry Potter show is expected to debut in 2026.
This combination also worked for the Harry Potter movies, which featured a number of experienced actors in adult roles but welcomed newcomers as well. This setup allowed many of the stars to become synonymous with their characters, and that could become the case for the remake’s actors too. Of course, they’ll have to overcome the challenge of having such great predecessors — but thus far, things look hopeful. Now all that’s left is to cast promising players as Voldemort and the Golden Trio — some of the most important additions to the series.
